Q & A

image

A good majority of the fan-fiction I read about
Belarus is about how she’s obsessed with Russia. Is there more to her than just
her obsession? I know she’s really really likes Russia but I want to believe
that’s not all to her character.

Honestly, no. Her
obsession is what shows up in most of her appearances. This doesn’t mean that
she can’t act normal, though. I have a post dedicated to showing that [x]. However,
even in the moments where she’s not hostile or aggressive, the gimmick still
ends up relating back to Russia.

It’s unfortunate, but
that’s just how it is. I’m still waiting for Himaruya to do something with her
character, as she’s only had one appearance in World Stars. It’s not even a
full appearance…

Source: Hetascanlations, World Stars Chapter 235.

image

I’m not an expert or anything, but I think
Canada has some symptoms of having abandoned child syndrome (ACS) or something
similar to it. Almost any official story arc involving him is about how he’s
neglected by everyone, his own family too. Poor baby I just want him to be
happy D’:

Without a doubt, Canada
was neglected as a child, but it’s not to the extent of abandoned child
syndrome. I’m also iffy on your claim that he’s neglected in every arc he’s
portrayed in. In fact, a key theme of America and Canada’s relationship—which
is depicted in more depth in World stars—shows that Canada is actually taken
for granted by America. America relied on Canada to follow his every command;
Canada’s character development revolved around him learning how to stand up for
himself.

I’m always hesitant to
medicalize characters because often enough labels like abandoned child syndrome
are thrown around without any substantiation, leading to exaggerated and
inaccurate conclusions (very similar to false claims that Chibitalia suffered
from Stockholm Syndrome).

The only symptom I would
say that Canada does have is guilt and believing that he did something wrong/
something is wrong with him that caused the neglect + accompanying
feelings of depression. Otherwise, he doesn’t have clinginess, he doesn’t
experience withdrawal from social activities, he isn’t resistant towards
others, he doesn’t have any sleeping or eating disorders, and he doesn’t have a
problem with substance abuse.

Source: Hetascanlations, World Stars Chapter 180. 

image

Oh, and I’m not an expert either ^^


Hey,
why do you think Germany doesn’t share the same last name as Prussia?

I agree with Hetarchive’s perspective on this. They believe
that the last name wasn’t given in order to leave more ambiguity in the relationship
between Holy Rome and Germany. They also go on to point out that the founder of
the Holy Roman Empire was named Ludwig (actually Louis, but Ludwig is the
German name version of Louis).


Hey Ella, do you have a theory as to why
Veneziano and Romano call Rome grandpa and not father? Is it a term of
endearment like “big brother” or are they actually blood related? And
if so do you think there was another nation between them and Rome that would be
their parent but didn’t last long? I’ve been wondering about that since day one
😅

No theory needed. It’s confirmed that they’re biologically
related. Their descendancy is confirmed through a curl of all things. It’s used
to discount Romania’s claim that he’s biologically related to Rome in spite of
being largely influenced by the latter’s culture.

Based on what I’ve seen in the manga, I think
the grandpa label is interchangeable and they just used what felt right to
them. Rome was older when the two of them were born, so ‘Grandpa’ likely felt
more appropriate in spite of the fact that he was their sole parent figure.

Source: Hetascanlations, World Stars Chapter 163.

image

 Another example: Ancient Egypt had a more
youthful appearance, which could explain why Egypt refers to her as Mom.

image

Is it true that England once hired China and India
to cook for him?

Yes. It’s meant to represent their cuisine’s
growing influence in his country.

Source: Hetascanlations, World Stars Chapter 291. 

image

Out of context, it looks like a sitcom…

*insert laugh track*

image

Hey! So I’ve already bookmarked the posts from your directory but I was wondering if you could provide me with a list of all the strips that debunk claims that Hetalia is fascist (etc.) My friend refuses to read your posts, so a list would be really nice :)

Well, don’t force them lol.

I just wish people would take the time to read the actual source material before making such inaccurate assumptions. Of course, this doesn’t mean that Hetalia doesn’t have its fair share of legitimate controversies, though.

There’s more evidence in previous posts I made, but these are core strips I always use.

Why Hetalia doesn’t promote fascism:

  • The Austrian Anschluss (Non-linear)
  • Main Storyline Chapter 4 (Original Webcomic)
  • Volume 1, Axis Powers pt. 1

Why Hetalia doesn’t promote imperialism:

  • France and the Olympia Romance (Non-linear)
  • The story about the early days of China and Japan (Non-linear)

Why Hetalia isn’t racist:

  • Fly, Canada-San Fly! (Non-linear)

Why Hetalia Doesn’t Promote War:

  • Volume 1, Axis Powers pt. 1
  • We’re Shipwrecked Too (non-linear)
  • Volume 1, 🙂 in the world
  • World Stars Chapter 120 & 129
  • Volume 3, United States of Hetalia
  • Volume 3, A Battlefield’s Kickoff
image
image

Did you send this to multiple blogs? I already saw this in my dash.


I get what you’re saying, I really do. But I also think that
you’ve set yourself up for disappointment. The expectations you’ve set up for
Hetalia were never meant to be met in the first place. It’s one thing if
Hetalia was based on a premise of historical and cultural accuracy, but it isn’t.
It’s based on stereotypes and poking fun at their inaccuracies.

By definition, stereotypes are inaccurate and exaggerated,
even though there may be partial truths behind them.

I’ve said this before, but to come to Hetalia expecting historical
accuracy is like going to McDonald’s and expecting a three-course meal. You can’t really get irritated for not finding something in a place where it was never meant to
be found.

Obviously, this shouldn’t be taken as a blanket statement defending Hetalia in its entirety. It’s had its fair share of faults and legitimate controversies. 

Anyways, I’ve done more in-depth posts on this if you’d
like to give them a read-through!

 [x] [x]