image

Note: This post
is making the assumption that Germany was reincarnated from Holy Rome. The rest
is all canon material.

All right! In canon, we know that reincarnation is possible.
The most obvious example would be Jeanne d’Arc and her American reincarnation,
Lisa.

What people often forget is that Hima explicitly states that
it’s possible for the nations to be reincarnated too.

In these panels, Hima makes it clear for us what a nation’s
existence and lifespan is like. They can last for really short or really long
periods of time and can be brought back by a sudden memory. More importantly, is
that nations can change their titles and ultimately, their personalities.

Following this logic, this would explain why Holy Rome and
Germany share some personality differences.

Where Germany is more clear-headed, rational,
and organized, Holy Rome is emotional and sensitive, irrational, impulsive, and
disorganized. I think Hima does this on purpose as a pun to contrast how at
first, Holy Rome was a disorganized collection of nation-states and then became more organized after unification and the subsequent formation of Germany. 

Just to highlight this, I’ll go over some quick examples. We
see some of Holy Rome’s impulsiveness not only with his obsession and
compulsion in getting Chibitalia to live in his house, but also in his
interactions with other countries.

What immediately comes to mind for me is how Holy Rome built
an Italian home in England, without even considering how the architecture
wasn’t designed to endure the harsher English climate.

It would be unprecedented for Germany to pull off something
like that, as he’s always rationalizing and thinking things through enough
times to drive anyone crazy.

You see the organization pun come to life with Germany’s
love for schedules, manuals, and the scientific method. Overall, he’s a much
deeper and rational thinker than Holy Rome.

Further, with unity, comes a stronger sense of national
duty.

On the other hand, due to the fragmentation in his empire,
Holy Rome doesn’t seem to care what happens to it and is more focused on
chasing after Italy. He’s even scolded for neglecting his duties by
Switzerland. Tell me, have you ever seen Germany slack off?

That said, there are more similarities between them than
differences, and Hima sure loves to stress this all throughout the series. They
both share a love for the Italian culture and climate, are flustered easily,
love sweets, own dogs, have Prussia as on older brother, and…

there’s also the obvious fact that they look exactly alike.

Who are the Schuyler sisters?

                            Hamiltalia:

Lithuania as Angelica Schuyler 

Belarus as Eliza Schuyler 

Latvia as Peggy Schuyler


Work, work! The Satellite sisters! 

Natalia! 

Toris! 

And Raivis!  

image

Latvia: Vanya said not to leave alone 

Lithuania: Vanya doesn’t need to know 

image

Latvia: Vanya said not to go out West

Lithuania: Like I said, you’re free to go (not really

image

But—look around, look around, the
Revolution’s happening in America! 

America!

I don’t want to bother you right now because you have so many asks but thank you for taking the time to answer our burning questions/theories! Whenever you post something I just get so excited to see what you’ve written!

This genuinely made me really happy! I want people to see that Hetalia is actually brilliant once you go past the surface level and take the time to read into it. If my posts make you excited, it means I’m doing my job 🙂

It always irks me when people say “The fandom is better than the strips” in terms of depth. Like no, there’s so much thought and care put into literally everything. 

Hetalia is not simple. It never was.

Im not Italian but I live in an Italian centric neighborhood and have been taking the language 4 the past 13 years in school. Im honestly not surprised that theres 2 italies-the north n south are so different. a good movie that really demonstrates this is “benvenuti al sud” (Im probably spelling welcome wrong orz) even between states/dialects, Italians r so bloody different. From physical appearances to the way they speak “italian” to individual prejudices against other Italians. Its uncanny.

Yes, exactly 🙂 Some of the prejudices you mentioned are captured in the strips too! This particular panel takes place during the Industrial Revolutions. 

image

Note: This is not
a theory. All I am doing is presenting canon information to help people better understand
the topic at hand.

image

Despite all the countless evidence explaining why Italy and
Romano remain as separate personifications, it seems as if the entire fandom
has conveniently forgotten about this. Shame on you all for pulling a Germany
and becoming amnesiacs!

Nah, I’m just kidding! But really, the number of strips that
explain why they’re separate personifications is overwhelming if you add them
all together. First, let’s start with the strip that makes this reasoning as plain
as day.

In chapter 20 of World Stars (the web comic), Hima states that the Italy brothers
are separate personifications not just because of regional differences, but
also because of their difficult cultures (which includes different dialects)
and histories.

image
image
image

On example of these differences, Romano has Spanish and some
Arabic influence, whereas Italy Veneziano has German blood in him. This is likely
attributed to how they were continuously conquered and divided by larger
foreign powers (ex: Spain, HRE, the Austro-Hungarian Empire).

image

Hima was also very careful to differentiate Italian Unification
from German Unification. The Italy brother’s unification process was rushed and
forced. It was artificial and symbolic more than anything else; in reality, it
wasn’t true unity.

image

Meanwhile, while the other German nations were also separate
personifications, their unity was a much smoother process and established more
solidarity throughout the country. It’s for this reason that only one
personification, Germany, was needed.

image

You can even tell that Hima was a bit frustrated in having
to explain this all to the readers (again),
as he finishes the scene with these sassy panels:

image
image

Honestly, given how many times Hima has stated these
differences and distinctions throughout the series, I would be annoyed too.
After this strip, however, the reasoning for why there are two Italian
personifications is 100% obvious.

You’ll see that Hima has been explaining these differences
right from the very start. Without further ado, let’s go over some of the many examples provided.

Due to Spanish influence, those in the island of Sardinia “still use Spanish.” Although, others have informed me that this influence is only in the dialect and that Sardinians don’t actually speak Spanish. 

image

Here, Hima makes a clear distinction between the cultures,
personalities, and economies of the North and South. 

image

Oops! More Spanish influence on Southern Italy (cuisine).

image

A small map that reveals what the regions are known for.

North Italy = Arts, Cars, and Tourism

South Italy = Primarily agriculture + has a mafia problem.

image

Although, it’s important to mention that North Italy has also had things stolen from him by the
mafia. Point is, the mafia is a much more prevalent problem in the Southern
half of the country, especially with kidnappings.

All right, I think I made my point. Both Italy brothers are
here to stay, so you don’t have to worry about one of them fading away any time
soon.

image

I’d like to point out one thing, if I can. Technically, since Italy is unified, doesn’t that mean one of the Italies doesn’t need to be here anymore? I’ve been looking through your blog and have been reading the Germany/Prussia theories. If we’re going with the younger brother route, wouldn’t Romano fade away?

image
image
image

Well, you guys asked for it, so here it is 🙂 Believe it or
not, it’s not even a theory. What I will present later is nothing more than
canon information. Hima must have reiterated the fact that both Italies are
different from each other close to thirty times (if I’m going by my old notes,
I’m sure there’s much more
). That’s why the North and South require a separate personification.

In other words, there is no one true Italy. Both Italies will continue to exist and neither
will fade. You’ll also see that even Hima got a bit fed up with people asking
for an explanation, despite how clear he’s made it that they’re different! He’s
explained it all throughout the strips (old and new), but it seems that people have ignored
it, because angst, am I right?

That said, there really shouldn’t be any theories out there
speculating that one Italy will fade in light of the other one remaining. Their
situation is much different from the German brothers, especially with the
cultural and historical notes that Hima provides for their dual existence.